This is the fifth in a series of posts covering the Healthy Aging Checklist, which is my list of six fundamental activities that will help any older adult maintain the best possible health while aging.
They are:
- Promote brain health and emotional well-being.
- Promote physical health.
- Check for and address common senior health problems (such as falls, memory concerns, depression, incontinence, pain, isolation, polypharmacy).
- Learn to optimize the management of any chronic conditions.
- Get recommended preventive health services for older adults.
- Address medical, legal, and financial advance care planning.
In this post, I’ll cover recommended preventive health services for older adults, based on the recommendations of the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force (USPSTF) and also Medicare’s coverage of preventive health services.
By my count, based on the USPSTF and Medicare guidelines, there are currently 26 preventive health services that older adults should consider. I have a summary list here, and then detailed information on each service starting here.
But before you read about them, let’s go over the basics of how preventive health services work, including why they can sometimes be harmful, or sometimes fall out of favor.
This way, when you review the list of preventive services to consider, you’ll better understand which services are likely to help, and why certain services may not be a good fit for you or your parent.
Understanding Preventive Health Services
Preventive health services essentially fall into three categories:
- Screening for health problems that are not yet causing symptoms noticeable to the patient. This includes some forms of cancer screening, as well as screening for conditions like high blood pressure or high blood sugar, which generally don’t cause symptoms.
- Checking for common problems that do cause symptoms but are easily overlooked in routine clinical care. This includes asking patients about things like depressive symptoms, falls, or even checking for signs of alcohol misuse.
- Administration of vaccines or medications to reduce the risk of a future illness.
In 2011, Medicare began offering a variety of preventive health services for free, because the 2010 Affordable Care Act mandated preventive care with no cost-sharing. (Whereas in traditional fee-for-service Medicare, beneficiaries may need to pay 20% of costs.) However, for services to be free, they may need to be ordered during the Annual Wellness Visit. For more information, see here.
What To Know About Preventive Health Services in Older Adults
Here are 3 key things to know:
1. For a preventive service to be recommended, there should be proof that providing this service results in improved health outcomes for most people.
You should know that for screening or early-detection services to improve health outcomes, clinicians must be routinely able to follow-up with a treatment that works, or somehow improves the health and wellbeing of the patient.
Furthermore, there needs to be proof that the screening or early-detection works better than waiting for the problem to become more symptomatic.
2. Many frequently offered screening services are not currently endorsed by the USPSTF, because research has not proven that detecting certain problems leads to better outcomes.
For instance, screening for prostate cancer by checking prostate-specific antigen (PSA) levels in older men is no longer recommended, because research found that overall screening didn’t save many lives, but did cause men to undergo many painful biopsies or treatment of small prostate cancers that probably would never have troubled them.
In other words, not all testing is useful. Especially when it comes to people with no symptoms, testing can often be harmful, or, at least, wasteful.
However, quite a lot of doctors will offer all kinds of screening and preventive tests, either because they have not kept up with the latest recommendations or because they make money when they do the tests. So it’s essential for you to be informed and learn more about a screening test before proceeding.
3. Many preventive health services become optional — or sometimes even recommended against — when people reach a certain age or state of poor health.
That’s because many preventive services have only been shown to be effective in people likely to live another 5-15 years.
This makes sense when you think about it: prevention services for a relatively healthy person aged 70 will not be the same as what might be recommended for a person who is 82 and has moderate-stage Alzheimer’s disease.
For more on estimating life-expectancy in older adults, you can visit ePrognosis.org, a site created by my colleagues in the UCSF Division of Geriatrics. I especially like their easy-to-use online app to help older adults and families make cancer screening decisions.
About the USPSTF and Its Recommendations
The USPSTF is an independent, volunteer panel of national experts in prevention and evidence-based medicine. Here is a quote from their about page:
[The USPSTF] recommendations are based on a rigorous review of existing peer-reviewed evidence and are intended to help primary care clinicians and patients decide together whether a preventive service is right for a patient’s needs.
The Task Force assigns each recommendation a letter grade (an A, B, C, or D grade or an I statement) based on the strength of the evidence and the balance of benefits and harms of a preventive service.
Broadly speaking, the USPSTF recommendations come in three key flavors. After carefully reviewing the scientific evidence and specifying what types of patients the recommendation applies to (e.g. age range, gender), they will recommend either “for,” “against,” or “neither for nor against” (which means they are not taking a stand either way).
The USPSTF also uses a grading system, which you can learn about here.
Summary of Preventive Services For Older Adults to Consider
Many preventive services for older adults can be checked on as part of the Medicare Annual Wellness Visit.
Remember, some types of prevention are unlikely to help older adults who are very old, very frail, or in poor health due to chronic illnesses. This is especially true with cancer screening.
So before proceeding with any of these services, be sure to review the details section below, to learn more about whether this service is recommended for someone like you or your older relative.
Here is a summary list, which I’ve organized into six key categories:
Preventive Services For Older Adults
The following preventive services are recommended for some or all older adults. Click on the category to jump down to detailed information about the services.
- Mental health, cognitive health, and substance use
- Checking for depression
- Checking for tobacco use
- Checking for alcohol misuse
- Checking for signs of cognitive impairment
- Safety and functional ability
- Asking about falls
- Checking for signs of functional impairment and assessing home safety
- Checking for signs of elder mistreatment
- Physical health
- Screening for high blood pressure
- Screening for high cholesterol
- Screening for obesity
- Screening for abnormal blood glucose and type 2 diabetes
- Screening for abdominal aortic aneurysm
- Screening for osteoporosis
- Screening for hepatitis C
- Screening for HIV
- Screening for other sexually transmitted infections
- Cancer screening
- Screening for colorectal cancer
- Screening for breast cancer
- Screening for cervical cancer
- Screening for lung cancer
- Screening for prostate cancer
- Vaccinations
- Influenza
- Pneumococcal disease (commonly known as the “pneumonia vaccines”)
- Shingles (herpes zoster)
- Tetanus-diphtheria (Td) and tetanus-diphtheria-pertussis (Tdap)
- Medications for prevention
- Aspirin for the prevention of cardiovascular disease and colorectal cancer
I’m also including information on two types of prevention that are not currently recommended by the USPSTF:
- Screening for coronary artery disease or other cardiovascular disease with ECG, carotid artery testing, and “non-traditional” risk factors
- Vitamin D for the prevention of falls
Advance care planning (which includes completion or review of advance directives) is also usually included in a list of preventive care services, but I will cover that in my next post, which will focus on medical, legal, and financial advance care planning.
Details on Recommended Preventive Services for Older Adults
Mental Health, Substance Use, and Cognitive Health
Recommended by the USPSTF:
- Depression:
- Who: All adults, including older adults. No upper age limit.
- How often: Unspecified per the USPSTF. Yearly screenings are covered by Medicare.
- For more information:
- Tobacco Use:
- Who: All adults
- How often: Unspecified by USPSTF. However, most electronic health record systems have been designed to prompt clinicians to record tobacco use routinely.
- For more information:
- Alcohol Misuse:
- Who: All adults
- How often: Unspecified by the USPSTF. Yearly screening is covered by Medicare.
- For more information:
Not recommended for or against by the USPSTF, but covered by Medicare:
- Cognitive Impairment:
- Who: For community-dwelling older adults with no signs or symptoms of cognitive impairment, screening is not recommended for or against by the USPSTF. However, “detection of any cognitive impairment” is specified as part of Medicare’s Annual Wellness Visit.
- How often: N/A for USPSTF. Covered yearly as part of Medicare’s Annual Wellness Visit.
- Notes: Medicare’s guide for doctors says clinicians should “assess the beneficiary’s cognitive function by direct observation, with due consideration of information obtained via beneficiary reports and concerns raised by family members, friends, caretakers, or others.”
- Medicare’s guide leaves healthcare providers with considerable latitude in how they can assess cognition and “detect” cognitive impairment.
- For more information:
Safety and Functional Ability
Recommended by the USPSTF:
- Falls (assessment for high risk of falling):
- Who: Adults over age 65
- How often: Not specified by the USPSTF. Covered yearly by Medicare Annual Wellness Visit.
- Notes: Medicare’s guide for clinicians does not specify exactly how a clinician should assess fall risk. The CDC provides resources here.
- For more information:
Not recommended for or against by the USPSTF but covered by Medicare:
- Functional ability and safety in the home:
- Who: All older adults
- How often: Covered yearly as part of Medicare’s Annual Wellness Visit
- Notes: Functional ability includes:
- the ability to manage activities of daily living (ADLs), which includes walking, dressing, bathing
- the ability to manage instrumental activities of daily living (IADLs), which includes transportation, shopping, meal preparation, medication management, and more
- vision and hearing
- cognitive abilities (see section on screening for cognitive impairment)
- Additional note: Medicare does not specify how to assess home safety
- For more information:
Not recommended for or against by the USPSTF but a Medicare quality measure, and generally recommended by many experts:
- Elder mistreatment:
- Who: All older adults
- Notes: Screening for elder maltreatment is included in Medicare’s quality improvement program for clinicians. However, it is not specified as part of the Annual Wellness Visit.
- For more information:
Physical Health
Recommended by the USPSTF and covered by Medicare:
- High blood pressure
- Who: All older adults
- How often: Yearly for people aged 40 or older. Covered as part of Medicare Annual Wellness Visit.
- For more information:
- High cholesterol
- Who: Adults aged 40-75 years old.
- How often: Per the USPSTF, about every 5 years; adjust based on previous results. Medicare covers cholesterol tests every 5 years as part of preventive care.
- Notes:
- The USPSTF used to recommend screening for lipid disorders, but this recommendation was retired in 2016. It was replaced by a related (but slightly different) recommendation, “Statin Use for the Primary Prevention of Cardiovascular Disease.”
- Measuring cholesterol is part of assessing a person’s “10-year cardiovascular event risk,” which is being used to move from “one size fits all” prevention recommendations to prevention that is tailored to a person’s individual health risks.
- For more information:
- Obesity (measurement of body-mass index)
- Who: all adults
- How often: Not specified by the USPSTF. Covered yearly as part of Medicare Annual Wellness Visit.
- For more information:
- Abnormal blood glucose and Type 2 Diabetes
- Who: Per the USPSTF, screening is recommended for adults aged 40-70 who are obese. Medicare covers screening for people with one or more risk factors, and doesn’t specify an age range.
- How often: About every three years, per the USPSTF. Covered every 12 months by Medicare, for people with risk factors.
- For more information:
- Abdominal Aortic Aneurysm
- Who: Men aged 65-75 who have smoked
- How often: Once per the USPSTF. Covered by Medicare if referred based on the Welcome to Medicare visit.
- For more information:
- Osteoporosis
- Who: Women aged 65+
- How often: Not specified by the USPSTF. Covered once every two years by Medicare.
- Notes: The USPSTF also recommends screening for post-menopausal women younger than 65, if a clinical fracture assessment tool indicates they are at increased risk of osteoporosis.
- For more information:
- Hepatitis C
- Who: The USPSTF recommends a one-time screening for all adults born between 1945 and 1965.
- How often: Covered at least once by Medicare for adults born during the years above. May be covered more often for those with additional risk factors for hepatitis C infection.
- For more information:
- HIV (Human immunodeficiency virus)
- Who: Adults aged 15-65, and older adults at increased risk for infection
- How often: Not specified by the USPSTF. Covered annually by Medicare.
- Notes: Older adults at increased risk for HIV infection may include men who have sex with men, people with multiple partners, and people with past or present injection drug use.
- For more information:
- Other Sexually Transmitted Infections (STIs)
- Who: Per the Centers for Disease Control (CDC), adults of all ages should be assessed for risk factors for STIs. Those with risk factors should be tested for STIs (usually includes chlamydia, gonorrhea, and syphilis; may include screening for other infections as well).
- Per the CDC, sexually active adults at risk for STIs include women with a new sexual partner and men who have sex with men. There is no upper age limit for these risk factors.
- How often: Assessment of STI risk factors is covered as part of the Medicare Annual Wellness visit. Medicare covers testing if a clinician determines a person has risk factors.
- Notes: The USPSTF recommended screening for syphilis in high-risk adults in 2004, and is now in the process of updating its recommendations.
- For more information:
- Who: Per the Centers for Disease Control (CDC), adults of all ages should be assessed for risk factors for STIs. Those with risk factors should be tested for STIs (usually includes chlamydia, gonorrhea, and syphilis; may include screening for other infections as well).
Not recommended by the USPSTF and not covered by Medicare as part of preventive care:
- Other Screenings for Coronary Artery Disease and Other Cardiovascular Disease
- The USPSTF has reviewed the evidence for the following screening tests and has chosen to not recommend them for adults with no symptoms:
- Using ECG to screen for coronary heart disease
- Using “non-traditional” risk factors to screen for coronary heart disease (see link for a list of these risk factors)
- Screening for carotid artery stenosis
- Screening for peripheral artery disease with the ankle-brachial index test
- Atrial Fibrillation: Screening With Electrocardiography
- The USPSTF has reviewed the evidence for the following screening tests and has chosen to not recommend them for adults with no symptoms:
Cancer Screening
Recommended by the USPSTF:
- Colorectal cancer
- Who: The USPSTF recommends for routine colon cancer screening for adults aged 50-75. For adults aged 76-85, the USPSTF recommends an individualized decision. The USPSTF does not recommend routine colon cancer screening for adults aged 86 or older.
- How often: This depends on the screening method used. Screening colonoscopy can be done every 10 years, whereas screening by checking stool for microscopic blood requires annual stool testing.
- Notes: For adults aged 76-85, the USPSTF notes that people who have never been screened for colon cancer may be more likely to benefit. The USPSTF is in the process of updating its guideline on colorectal cancer screenings.
- For more information:
- Breast cancer
- Who: The USPSTF recommends for routine breast cancer screening in women aged 50-74. The USPSTF recommends neither for nor against breast cancer screening in women aged 75 or older.
- How often: The USPSTF recommends screening mammography every two years. Medicare covers screening mammograms every 12 months.
- For more information:
- Cervical cancer
- Who: The USPSTF recommends against cervical cancer screening in women aged 65+ who “have had adequate prior screening and are not at high risk.” They also recommend against cervical cancer screening in women who have had a hysterectomy for non-cancer reasons.
- Older women who have never been screened for cervical cancer, or did not get a Pap smear between the ages of 55-65, should be screened at least once.
- How often: Medicare covers a Pap smear every 24 months for women who are deemed low-risk for cervical or vaginal cancer, and every 12 months for women who are at high risk.
- Notes: Adequate prior screening for cervical cancer means having had three negative Pap smears in a row, with the most recent test within five years.
- For more information:
- Who: The USPSTF recommends against cervical cancer screening in women aged 65+ who “have had adequate prior screening and are not at high risk.” They also recommend against cervical cancer screening in women who have had a hysterectomy for non-cancer reasons.
- Lung cancer
- Who: Per the USPSTF, adults who are age 55-80, have a 30 pack-year history of smoking, and either smoke or have quit within the past 15 years.
- How often: The USPSTF recommends yearly screening for the adults meeting the criteria above, and stopping screening once it’s been 15 years since the person quit smoking. Medicare covers the yearly screening test for people aged 55-77 who otherwise meet the USPSTF criteria.
- For more information:
Not clearly recommended by the USPSTF:
- Prostate cancer:
- Who: The USPSTF used to recommend against using the prostate-specific antigen (PSA) test to screen for prostate cancer. However, in 2018 they changed to recommending an individualized screening decision for men aged 55-69, and recommended against screening men aged 70+. The American College of Physicians recommends an individualized screening decision for men aged 50-69, and recommends against screening in men aged 70+ or with life expectancy less than 10-15 years.
- How often: Medicare covers a PSA test and digital rectal exam every 12 months.
- For more information:
Vaccinations
The USPSTF does not issue recommendations regarding vaccinations. For this section, I will refer to recommendations from the CDC’s Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices (ACIP).
- Influenza (flu) vaccine
- Who: The CDC recommends vaccination for seasonal influenza every year, for everyone aged 6 months or older. There is no upper age limit. A high-dose influenza vaccine (Fluzone) is approved for adults aged 65+, and may be better at stimulating an aging immune system.
- How often: Yearly in the fall, once the year’s vaccine becomes available.
- Notes: The flu vaccine cannot give a person the flu, although some mild side-effects are possible, including achiness or fever. Generally, the flu shot has a very low risk of harm. The likelihood of benefit depends on how well matched the vaccine is to the circulating influenza virus in a given year.
- For more information:
- Pneumococcal vaccination (two types as of 2014)
- Who: All adults aged 65+ should get both Prevnar (PCV13) and Pneumovax (PPSV23).
- How often: Once for each, after age 65. The CDC recommends revaccinating high-risk patients who received Pneumovax prior to age 65, once it’s been five years since Pneumovax was first administered.
- Notes: These are often called “pneumonia shots” but technically they vaccinate against Streptococcus pneumoniae, a bacterium that can cause serious illness both inside and outside the lungs. Bear in mind that many viruses and other bacteria can cause pneumonia.
- Previously, only Pneumovax (PPSV23) was recommended for all adults aged 65+. In 2014, the CDC recommended that older adults also receive Prevnar (PCV13), another type of pneumococcal vaccine that offers complementary protection.
- Prevnar and Pneumovax should not be administered at the same time; a 6-12 month interval between them is required.
- It is ok to receive either pneumococcal vaccination at the same time as a different vaccine altogether, such as seasonal influenza vaccine or zoster vaccine.
- For more information:
- Shingles (herpes zoster) vaccine
- Who: The CDC recommends vaccination with the newer vaccine Shingrix, for most older adults aged 50+. Vaccination with Shingrix is also recommended for older adults who have previously been vaccinated with the older vaccine Zostavax, because research indicates that the effect of Zostavax wanes after five years.
- How often: Shingrix vaccination requires a second injection, to be given 2-6 months after the initial Shingrix injection. Medicare covers shingles vaccination as part of a person’s Part D plan.
- Once the two doses of Shingrix have been administered, re-vaccination later in life is not currently recommended.
- Vaccination with a single dose of Zostavax is an option, for relatively healthy adults aged 60+. However, the CDC says that Shingrix is preferred, as it appears to be much more effective and long-lasting.
- Notes: Shingles is extremely common: nearly 1 in 3 people gets shingles at some point in their life, usually when they are older. Of those who get shingles, 1 in 6 will develop a related chronic pain condition called post-herpetic neuralgia.
- Per the CDC, the Shingrix vaccine is 91-97% effective in preventing shingles. In comparison, research suggests that Zostavax decreases the risk of shingles by 51%.
- For more information:
- Tetanus-diphtheria (Td) and tetanus-diptheria-pertussis (Tdap)
- Who: The CDC recommends a Td booster shot every 10 years for all adults. In 2010, the CDC recommended that adults of all ages get one dose of Tdap to get protection against pertussis (whooping cough), which has become more common.
- Pertussis vaccination is especially important for those who will be around young babies, such as grandparents or childcare providers.
- How often: The Td booster should be given every 10 years. Currently, Tdap is recommended once for adults aged 65+ who have not previously received Tdap in adulthood. Both Td and Tdap are covered under Medicare Part D.
- For more information:
- Who: The CDC recommends a Td booster shot every 10 years for all adults. In 2010, the CDC recommended that adults of all ages get one dose of Tdap to get protection against pertussis (whooping cough), which has become more common.
Medications for Prevention
Recommended by the USPSTF:
- Aspirin for the Prevention of Cardiovascular Disease and Colorectal Cancer
- Who: For adults aged 60-69, who have at least a 10% chance of a cardiovascular event within 10 years, the USPSTF recommends an individualized decision on whether to take a daily low dose aspirin for primary prevention, provided the person is not at increased risk for bleeding and is likely to live at least another 10 years.
- Notes: Aspirin used to be more widely recommended to prevent heart attacks and strokes, but now the USPSTF is encouraging a more personalized approach in which doctors and patients review the likely benefits and harms.
- The USPSTF does currently recommend daily low-dose aspirin for adults aged 50-59, if they appear to have at least a 10% chance of a cardiovascular event, and are likely to live at least another 10 years.
- For adults aged 70 or older, the USPSTF currently states that the evidence is insufficient to assess the likely benefits and harms of aspirin for primary prevention.
- These recommendations apply to adults without a known history of heart attack or stroke.
- For more information:
No longer recommended by the USPSTF:
- Vitamin D for Prevention of Falls
- Who: In 2012 the USPSTF recommended vitamin D supplementation in adults aged 65+ who are at increased risk for falls. However, in 2018 the USPSTF recommended against vitamin D for fall prevention, but noted that this recommendation applies to older adults not known to have osteoporosis or vitamin D deficiency.
- Notes: The USPSTF has evaluated vitamin D for other preventive purposes, such as fracture prevention, and stated that the evidence is inconclusive. (See here and here.)
- For more information:
What to Do Next
As you can see, there is a quite a long list of preventive health services that are recommended for older adults!
Fortunately, most don’t need to be addressed every year, and some may not apply to you or your older relative at all.
To make sure you get recommended preventive health services, I recommend using the free PDF cheatsheets summarizing these services as follows:
- Tick the checkbox if the preventive service applies to you (or your older relative).
- Find out if you are up-to-date on the service, by checking on when you last received it.
- Make a note of when the preventive service is next due, if applicable.
If you aren’t sure if a preventive service applies to you, make a note to discuss this with your doctors.
By making sure you have gotten those preventive health services that are recommended for people of your age or health circumstances — and by avoiding prevention that is unproven or unlikely to benefit people like you — you’ll be helping to ensure healthier aging.
Questions or comments about these preventive health services? Please post them below!
I like your general rule of, “If you aren’t sure if a preventive service applies to you, make a not to discuss this with your doctors.” My parents have been talking a lot about health checks and preventive measures lately. They are both in their mid 50’s and want to make sure they remain in good shape and health condition. They both understand that they could easily go down hill if they don’t take proactive steps to their health. We’ve actually just started a family health challenge, so that should help. Thanks for the list of everything to consider, it was helpful to read!
Glad you found this article helpful. Be sure to consider the information in the other posts related to the Healthy Aging Checklist, as those cover proven actions to maintain brain health, physical health, etc.
When my mother was in a nursing home the P.A. told me that at the age of 76 routine preventative procedures were no longer allowed. Is this true?
Well, flu shots are recommended for people of all ages and are especially recommended for older adults. So I don’t think it’s accurate to say that at a certain age, preventive procedures are no longer allowed. It really depends on what is the preventive procedure in question.
It also in many cases depends on the person’s likely life expectancy; if you are 50 but have advanced cancer and are unlikely to live more than a year, then many preventive procedures no longer make sense.
I have provided information on the age ranges that apply to the preventive services within the post.
Thanks for the terrific info for us seniors – saw your name and website in the Wall Street Journal today and a simple roadmap for senior health navigation is much appreciated! Had one question about shingles – I’m not sure when the 26 Proven Preventive Health Screenings area of the website was written, but I understand the newer Shingles vaccine “Shingrix” is much more effective than Zostavax but your website says Zostavax is the only approved vaccine. I received the Zostavax vaccine several years ago but my local pharmacist recommend the new vaccine as enhanced protection. Any suggestions? Should you update the the website?
Thanks for your comment, I have responded to a similar inquiry below. This article was originally published in March 2016 and was scheduled for an update later this spring. We are now hustling to revise it this week. (I did not know ahead of time about this WSJ piece; am honored to be mentioned though!)
I have updated the shingles information in the article. Yes, the CDC is recommending Shingrix over Zostavax, and is also recommending Shingrix for people previously vaccinated with Zostavax.
We will be updating the cheatsheet and sending it to everyone who has recently downloaded it.
So glad you found the article helpful. The remainder of the healthy aging series will be updated later this spring, but the general principles and recommendations are evergreen.
What about new shingles vaccine? Higher rate of prevention, though scarce…
Thanks for the question. I have updated the article with the more recent information related to the newer Shingrix vaccine. It is indeed recommended by the CDC as it seems to be more effective — and longer-lasting — than the older vaccine Zostavax. We will have the cheatsheet updated within a few days and will be sending the revised version to everyone who downloads the current one.
We’re also making a few other updates to the article, as preventive recommendations do change over time and it was due for a refresh.
Was pleasantly surprised that your excellent website has not crashed under the weight of so many Wall Street Journal aging readers searching for it, following the 7 Jan edition.
Your article is the most comprehensive I’ve read and the privacy policy and financial disclosure is also commendable. Thanks
Thank you, appreciate the feedback and glad you found the article helpful!
Great website, very helpful! I also found it through the recent WSJ article. Thank you for this service!
Thank you, so glad you found it useful.
Another WSJ reader visiting your site based on the Jan 7 mention. Congrats and thank you for this!
thank you!
Lung cancer: I totally disagree with your recommendation of cancer screening only for those who smoke or stopped smoking. I was diagnosed with lung cancer last month and have never smoked. It is a mistake to think only smokers get lung cancer. For me I coughed for months, was told on four doctor visits that it was bronchitis. Only when I started coughing up blood was my concern taken seriously. It’s my opinion doctors need to look beyond just smokers when considering lung cancer.
So sorry to hear of your lung cancer diagnosis.
Yes, it can and does occur in non-smokers, but the risk is much higher in smokers and that is why preventive screening is recommended for smokers. Please note that this recommendation is not “mine”, it is that of the US Preventive Services Task Force, and they make recommendations after very carefully reviewing research.
Also, preventive cancer screening is for people with NO symptoms. Once there are symptoms (such as cough, in your case), the issue become evaluation and diagnosis of a health concern, and not screening.
I hope they have caught your lung cancer early, good luck with your treatment.
Dear Doctor: thanks for providing a cheat sheet for us seniors (I am 67 male). I direct your attention to the CVD section which recommends against “non traditional screening techniques”. I am interested
screening for Lp(a): when I clicked on ‘non-traditional screening techniques”, the Lp(a) screening was not mentioned at all. But, when I clicked on “archives”, that section did include Lp(a) screening (implying that this was a non-traditional technique and was NOT recommended).
So, the guidelines seem to have changed re Lp(a) screenings for CVD in asymptomatic patients.
What is your view? Also, supposed a patient is asymptomatic, but has an earlier diagnosis of
CVD? Do you then recommend Lp(a) screening?
Thanks so much.
I don’t have a particular view on lipoprotein(a); I am not a cardiologist or specialist in this area. The whole point of these types of guidelines is for the USPSTF to do the work of carefully reviewing the scholarly evidence, and then distill their findings into guidance for generalists and others. I am not sure what to make of them not mentioning this measurement, when it was mentioned in a previous guideline. They also retired a previous guideline on screening for lipid disorders, so they may just be moving towards other ways to assess cardiovascular risk.
Generally, when it comes to whether to do a test, the question I ask myself is, how will this change management or our consideration of whether or not to pursue a certain type of therapy or treatment.
For someone who has a diagnosis of prior clinical CVD, these preventive care guidelines do not apply. There are other guidelines available for “secondary prevention” of CVD, meaning the prevention of a subsequent event in someone who has already had a heart attack, stroke, or other overt manifestation of cardiovascular disease.
Thank you for pointing out that preventative health services include forms of examination screenings, such as cancer, high blood pressure, and high blood sugar. I’ve been thinking about having a physical examination done. It has been a while since I have seen a professional in my area. It’s good to know that there are preventative health services available.
Dear Dr. Kernisan:
I’m truly impressed with your site. My only suggestion – as a layperson who has access to the top medical newsletters from Schools of Public Health – is it is a bit too ‘Americanized’ (e.g., the U.S.P.S.T.F.’s recommendations are wisely offered, but some modern Western governments differ somewhat with its conclusions as in vitamin D levels and safe amount of alcohol to drink, to name just two). I, also, respectfully disagree with the current ‘philosophy of pedagogy’ (I’ll call it) with regard to undergo preventative [not ‘preventive’] testing because only a small per cent of patients will benefit. I find this both a) paternal and b) patronizing especially with mammogram testing because women may be ‘scared off’ by false positives OR feel “”uncomfortable”” with inconvenient testing. Yet, that is a whole other discussion/debate. Even if I didn’t have two members of my family with prostate cancer, I would still have a PSA (unless the test is shown to be misleading). I surely like the sources you reference: not too simple (like the Mayo Clinic site) and not too technical (like the Medscape site–written for physicians) i.e., not watered-down nor medicalese in terminology.
I’d like to know your professional observation of the Stanford 25 checklist for an annual physical.
Respectfully,
Laurence
Thank you for your comment, I’m very glad if you find the site useful. Yes, it is Americanized, in part because the goal is to share what I consider “mainstream American geriatrics.” I find that this in of itself keeps me extremely busy, and so I don’t embark on trying to consolidate worldwide recommendations. I also generally don’t question the “mainstream” approach, which is usually to go with the recommendations of the USPSTF, CDC, etc. In short, I don’t see myself as there to question “mainstream geriatrics”, I am mainly there to share the info.
Regarding the Stanford 25, this is not intended to be a checklist for an annual physical. Instead, it’s a medical teaching resource and intended to help medical trainees (and practicing health providers) focus on various aspects of the clinical bedside exam. These different bedside exams are like tests and procedures; they should be done when it seems indicated, which essentially means when it seems relevant based on the patient’s symptoms or concerns. They are not meant to be a package done as part of a physical exam.
Rather than an annual physical, I would probably recommend that older adults go through the various suggestions I share in this healthy aging series 🙂
Certain issues could and should be discussed with one’s health provider, either during an annual visit or at other times. Hope this helps!