It’s October, which means it’s that time of the year again: flu vaccination time!
Back when I worked in a primary care clinic, this is when we made a big push to offer the seasonal flu shot to all of our patients. (And we got ourselves immunized, as well.)
Not all of our patients agreed. Many older adults are skeptical of the need to get a yearly vaccination against influenza. They aren’t sure it will help. Or they think that the vaccination will actually give them a mild case of the flu. Or they just don’t like needles.
Or maybe they aren’t sure which type of seasonal flu shot to get: the regular one or one of the newer “stronger” versions, designed for older adults?
I’m never surprised when people bring up these questions. Vaccination for seasonal influenza can indeed be a confusing topic.
But it’s certainly important to consider. Depending on the year, the Centers for Disease Control (CDC) estimates that every year, influenza affects 9-60 million Americans, causes 140,000-710,100 hospitalizations, and results in 12,000-56,000 deaths.
Influenza is more severe in some years than others. For instance, the 2017-2018 season was particularly severe, with an estimated 80,000 deaths related to the flu. The 2018-2019 season wasn’t as bad, but still had a real impact: the CDC estimates that there were 37.4 million to 42.9 million flu illnesses last year, causing an estimated 36,400 – 61,200 flu deaths.
Now, most people get better without needing hospitalization, but some people get very sick. Older adults are especially likely to get dangerously ill from catching the flu.
So I agree with the CDC’s recommendation: everyone over the age of 6 months should get their seasonal flu shot.
In fact, I’m about to go get mine. As a healthy woman in her 40s, I’m not that concerned about getting dangerously ill from influenza. Instead, I get my annual flu shot because I want to minimize my chance of getting sick and perhaps exposing my older patients to influenza.
This month, you’ll probably be encouraged to get vaccinated too. So in this article, I’ll address some key things to know about influenza and the flu shot, along with some common questions and concerns. Here’s what I’ll cover:
- The basics of influenza and vaccination against the flu
- What to know about flu shots for older adults
- What’s new and resources for the 2019-2020 flu season
- Which influenza vaccination is probably best for most older adults
- What to do if your older parent or relative is unwilling or unable to get vaccinated
The basics of influenza and vaccination against the flu
Q: What is influenza?
A: Influenza is a contagious respiratory viral illness, caused by influenza A or influenza B virus. It usually causes symptoms such as sore throat, stuffy nose, cough, fever, and body aches. In the Northern hemisphere, influenza is most common in the winter. Peak influenza activity usually occurs between December and February, but it can start as early as October and occur as late as May.
In “uncomplicated” influenza, the flu causes symptoms similar to — but usually worse than — a very bad cold, and then these get better over 5-7 days. Most people who catch the flu experience uncomplicated influenza, with some people experiencing more significant symptoms than others. In fact, some people (14%, in one study) will catch the flu and shed some flu virus, yet not report any symptoms!
However, influenza does sometimes cause more serious health problems, which we call “complications.” These are more likely to happen to people who are older, have other chronic conditions, or have a weakened immune system.
The most common complication of influenza is pneumonia, which means a serious infection of the lungs. Such cases of pneumonia are sometimes purely viral. But it’s more common for them to be caused by bacteria, who are able to infect the lungs due to the body being weakened by influenza infection.
Many older adults also appear to experience worsenings of any chronic heart or lung conditions, when they experience influenza. These complications of influenza often cause hospitalization or even death.
To learn more about the basics of influenza, and for more on diagnosing and treating the flu, see:
Q: How does the flu shot help protect one from influenza, and how effective is it?
A: The flu vaccine works by stimulating the body to produce antibodies against whatever strains of influenza were included in that year’s vaccine. After vaccination, it takes about two weeks for the body’s immune system to create its influenza antibodies.
Our bodies are able to fight off viral infections much more quickly if we already have matching antibodies available when a virus tries to create illness in our bodies. If we don’t have matching antibodies available, then we’ll experience more illness, and it will take longer for our immune systems to control the infection.
The tricky thing about influenza is this: both influenza A and B have a tendency to be constantly changing into slightly different strains. This means that every year, scientists must study what influenza strains are present, and try to predict which ones we’ll be exposed to, during the coming winter. Influenza vaccines are then developed, to match those strains. (This is why the flu shot has to be given every year.)
Sometimes the scientific prediction works out well. In this case, we say that the vaccine was well-matched to the influenza viruses circulating that winter, and influenza vaccination will have been more effective in preventing the flu.
But there are years in which the influenza strains that circulate the most in the winter are not the ones that scientists were expecting. These are the years in which the influenza vaccine is not well-matched, and there tends to be more illnesses and hospitalizations.
The CDC estimates that when the vaccine is well-matched to the circulating influenza viruses, flu vaccination reduces the risk of flu illness by between 40% and 60%, for the overall population.
Several different flu vaccines are available every year. “Trivalent” flu vaccines have been available for the longest: these protect against two strains of influenza A and one strain of influenza B. “Quadrivalent” flu vaccines, available since 2012, protect against two types of influenza A and two strains of influenza B.
Vaccines also vary in terms of whether they are “standard-dose” versus “high-dose,” and one type includes an “adjuvant,” which is an additive designed to increase the immune system’s response to the vaccine. (More response is better, in that it means more protection from future infection.) I’ll discuss high-dose and adjuvant vaccines later in this article, in the section addressing flu shots for aging adults.
You can find a list of all available influenza vaccines in the Table listed below.
For more information:
- Key Facts About Seasonal Flu Vaccine (CDC)
- Vaccine Effectiveness – How Well Does the Flu Vaccine Work? (CDC)
- Understanding How Vaccines Work (CDC)
- Influenza vaccines — United States, 2019–20 influenza season
Q: Can you get the flu from the flu shot? What are the risks and side effects of influenza vaccination?
A: No, you can’t get the flu from a flu shot. The currently recommended vaccines are made with either “inactivated” virus (which means the virus has been killed and can’t become alive again) or “recombinant” technology (which means they have cobbled together virus proteins). It is not possible for these vaccines to give you influenza.
There is also a “live attenuated” form of flu shot (FluMist), available for people ages 2-49, which is given by nasal spray. This contains a weakened form of influenza virus. This was not included on the CDC’s list of recommended flu vaccines for the 2016-17 and 2017-18 flu seasons but was approved again for the 2018-2019 flu season, and is approved again for 2019-2020. It has historically been popular with children. Some research suggests it’s less effective than the other flu vaccines, so in 2018 the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) recommended parents choose to vaccinate with an injectable flu vaccine instead. However, for 2019-2020, the AAP says either the injected or nasal vaccine is recommended for children.
The most common side-effect of the flu shot is arm soreness, and sometimes redness. People do sometimes report body aches, fever, or cough after the flu shot. But a randomized trial found that these are equally common in people who just had saline injected, so these symptoms are either due to getting sick from something else after your flu shot, or perhaps to even expecting to feel lousy after your flu shot.
Serious adverse effects related to the flu shot are very rare.
For more information:
Q: What are the best ways to protect oneself from influenza and its complications?
A: To reduce your risk of getting sick from the flu, it’s best to combine two approaches:
- Minimize your exposure to people spreading the influenza virus in the winter.
- Take steps to bolster your immune system, so that if you do get exposed to the influenza virus, you’ll be less likely to get very sick.
Older adults should also make sure they are up-to-date on pneumococcal vaccination. (These are one-time, not yearly). Pneumococcal vaccination helps reduce the risk of certain types of bacterial pneumonia and other potential complications of influenza. A 2016 meta-analysis concluded that being vaccinated for both influenza and pneumococcus was associated with a lower risk of pneumonia and death. For more on pneumococcal vaccination, see: 26 Preventive Services for Older Adults (Vaccination section).
Minimizing your exposure to influenza virus
The main way people get exposed to influenza is when they breathe in air droplets containing the influenza virus. These droplets are created when people infected with influenza virus talk, sneeze, or cough. The CDC estimates that a person infected with the influenza virus may be contagious for one day prior to developing symptoms, and 5-7 days after getting sick.
Influenza virus can also survive on hard household surfaces for up to a day. The virus survives for much less time on soft surfaces, such as used tissues and bed linens.
Based on these facts, the best ways to minimize exposure to influenza are to:
- Avoid exposure to people who may be infected with influenza.
- Clean household surfaces, especially hard surfaces such as counters, and especially if someone living with you has been sick.
- Wash your hands often, especially before touching your eyes, nose, or mouth.
- Minimize your time near people who have not been vaccinated for influenza.
- Your risk of influenza exposure is reduced if people around you — family members, co-workers, fellow residents of your living facility — are vaccinated for influenza.
Bolstering your immune system
Since we are social creatures and live in communities, we all have a good chance of being exposed to the influenza virus at some point. Whether we get sick from this exposure, and how sick we get, depends on how well our immune system can fight off the influenza virus.
Ways to bolster your immune system are:
- Be vaccinated against seasonal influenza. If the vaccine is a good match with circulating viruses and you have a good antibody response, this is probably the best way to prepare your immune system to beat influenza.
- Take good care of your health and body. This includes addressing healthy lifestyle basics such as not smoking, getting adequate sleep, avoiding chronic stress, and more. For a good review of what’s known about strengthening the immune system, see: How to boost your immune system (Harvard Health Review)
What to know about flu shots for older adults
Q: Is the flu vaccine effective for older adults?
A: You may have heard people say that the flu shot doesn’t work in older people. This is not entirely correct.
Now, it’s true that flu vaccine is usually less effective in older adults because aging immune systems tend to not respond as vigorously to the vaccine. In other words, older adults tend to create fewer antibodies in response to vaccination. So if they are later exposed to flu virus, they have a higher chance of falling ill, compared to younger adults.
But “less effective” doesn’t mean “not at all effective.” For the 2017-2018 flu season, the CDC estimates that vaccination prevented about 700,000 influenza cases and 65,000 hospitalizations, for adults aged 65 and older.
For more on the effectiveness of influenza vaccination in older adults, see:
- Vaccine Effectiveness – How Well Does the Flu Vaccine Work? (You can jump to the section “How effective is the flu vaccine in the elderly?” by using the “On this Page” menu, to the right.)
To provide more effective vaccination to aging immune systems, vaccine makers have developed “stronger” vaccines against the flu, which I explain in the next section.
Q: Are there flu shots specifically designed for older adults?
Yes, over the past several years, vaccine makers have developed vaccines that are designed to work better with an aging immune system. Most research studies to date show that these stimulate aging immune systems to produce more antibodies to influenza. There’s also some evidence that these vaccines reduce the risk of being hospitalized for influenza.
However, so far the CDC’s Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices (ACIP) has not particularly recommended these vaccines for older adults. Instead, the ACIP says that older adults should get any influenza vaccination approved for their age.
There are two influenza vaccines that are specifically approved for people aged 65 and older:
- Fluzone High-Dose: This trivalent vaccine contains four times the amount of antigen, compared to Fluzone standard-dose. It is approved for adults age 65+.
- Studies have found that the high-dose vaccine does improve antibody response. A study published in 2017 also found that use of the high-dose vaccine in nursing-homes was associated with a lower risk of hospitalization during flu season.
- Fluad: This trivalent vaccine contains an “adjuvant,” which is an additive meant to stimulate a better immune response to the vaccine. It is a newer vaccine in the U.S., but had been licensed in Canada and several European countries prior to receiving approval here in 2015.
- An Italian study found that this vaccine resulted in higher antibody titers, among older adults.
- But no recent clinical trials of efficacy have been published. (Which means we don’t yet know whether people given this vaccine actually have a lower chance of being hospitalized during flu season.)
For more information on flu shots for older adults, see:
- Fluzone High-Dose Seasonal Influenza Vaccine
- FLUAD Flu Vaccine With Adjuvant
- New Guidance Clarifies Use of Pneumococcal, Influenza Vaccines in Older Adults (this is for professionals working in long-term care, so more technical and includes good details regarding research evidence)
Q: Does Medicare cover the cost of influenza vaccination?
Yes, yearly influenza vaccination is 100% covered by Medicare, with no deductible or co-pay. So if you get your flu shot from a health provider that accepts Medicare payment, there should be no cost.
What’s new and resources for the 2019-2020 flu season
The CDC maintains a page dedicated to the current flu season. There is a section for the public and also a section for providers. This is a good place to get up-to-date information on influenza and influenza vaccination. You can find it here:
- 2019-2020 Flu Season (main page)
- Frequently Asked Flu Questions 2019-2020 Influenza Season (main page for the public)
The CDC also provides information specific to older adults here:
Which influenza vaccination is best for older adults?
Looking at the list of available flu shots can be overwhelming. In looking at this year’s CDC table of available influenza vaccines, I counted eight options that are available for people aged 65 or older:
- 4 standard-dose quadrivalent inactivated vaccines (Afluria Quadrivalent, Fluarix Quadrivalent, FluLaval Quadrivalent, Fluzone Quadrivalent)
- 1 standard-dose quadrivalent inactivated vaccine manufactured with a newer “cell culture-based” technology (Flucelvax Quadrivalent)
- 1 standard-dose trivalent adjuvanted inactivated vaccine (Fluad)
- 1 high-dose trivalent inactivated vaccine (Fluzone High-Dose)
- 1 quadrivalent recombinant vaccine (Flublok Quadrivalent)
Only Fluzone High-Dose and Fluad carry an age indication specific to 65 years or older.
However, the CDC does not recommend any influenza vaccine over another, for adults aged 65 or older.
So if you are an older adult, or if you’re trying to arrange a flu shot for an aging relative, which flu vaccine should you try to get?
My take is this: if you have a choice, go for one of the vaccines designed for older adults.
Why? Because we know that as people get older, their immune systems tend to respond less vigorously to immunization. And because research suggests that the high-dose flu shot generates higher antibody titers and has been associated with better influenza outcomes.
We do have more research and experience for Fluzone High-Dose than for Fluad, so unless you are enrolling in a clinical trial of Fluad, I would suggest going with the Fluzone High-Dose.
Now, both flu vaccines designed for older adults are trivalent and not quadrivalent. Quadrivalent vaccines do provide protection against an additional influenza B strain. However, experts say that older adults are less likely to be seriously ill from influenza B than from influenza A. Also, no published study has compared a quadrivalent vaccine against a high-dose trivalent vaccine. So for now, there does not seem to be a particular reason that an older adult should choose a quadrivalent vaccine over a high-dose trivalent vaccine.
You may have also heard that the New England Journal of Medicine published a study in 2017, about a newer influenza vaccine in older adults. That study, funded by the manufacturer of recombinant influenza vaccines, compared the effectiveness of a recombinant quadrivalent vaccine with a standard-dose quadrivalent inactivated vaccine, in adults aged 50 and older. Confirmed influenza cases were 2.2% in the group receiving recombinant vaccine and 3.2% in the group receiving inactivated vaccine. Hence the probability of influenza-like illness was 30% lower with the recombinant vaccine than with the inactivated vaccine. But again, this study did not compare the recombinant vaccine against a high-dose inactivated vaccine.
Bottom line:
- What is most important is to get any type of flu vaccination that is approved for your age.
- Research suggests that older adults are more likely to benefit from a high-dose influenza vaccination, such as Fluzone High-Dose.
- If you are under age 65, you might get better protection from an influenza vaccine that is quadrivalent compared to trivalent. You also might get better protection from a vaccine that is recombinant rather than made from an inactivated vaccine.
- Flumist, the nasally administered vaccine, is available only to people age 2-49, and so is not an option for older adults.
What to do if your older parent or relative is unwilling or unable to get vaccinated
Now, what if your older parent won’t, or can’t, get a flu shot?
Some older adults just don’t want to get it. Here are some things you can try:
- Ask them to clarify what their concerns are. It’s important to start by listening, in order to understand what an older person believes about the flu and the flu shot.
- Provide information to dispel myths and misunderstandings. Sometimes all people need is a little of the right kind of information.
- Point out that it can benefit an older person’s family members and neighbors. Getting a flu shot can reduce the risk that we pass the flu on to another person. People are sometimes more willing to take action to protect others than to protect their own health.
- Make sure they know they won’t have to pay for the flu shot. If you get the shot from a provider who takes Medicare, it shouldn’t cost anything.
- Offer to go together to get your flu shots. Sometimes it helps to make it a family outing.
There are also some older adults for whom it’s hard to get a flu shot, such as people who are homebound or have very limited transportation options.
If this is your situation, the main thing to do is encourage flu shots for family and others coming to the house. For older adults who don’t get out much, their main source of exposure to influenza will be from those who come to them.
Above all, don’t panic if your older loved one can’t or won’t get a flu shot.
Although I’ve just written a long article encouraging flu vaccination for older adults, the truth is this: most years, the chance of getting very sick or dying from influenza are small. (The 2017-2018 season was unusually severe; this year will probably be “usual.”)
Being vaccinated certainly helps make this chance smaller. But not every older person is interested in doing everything possible to reduce the danger of illness. Vaccination is important from a public health perspective, but most people survive flu season whether or not they’ve been vaccinated.
Personally, I think it’s worth getting vaccinated because there’s a small chance that you’ll avoid the misery of having influenza. And, there’s maybe an even better chance that you’ll help reduce the spread of influenza to people around you.
The downsides of getting a flu shot are small. You’ll have to get to a place where they are offering the flu shot. The needle poke will hurt for a moment. Your arm might be sore for a day or so.
And then that’s it! You’ll have done your small part to protect yourself and others.
So, have you decided where to go to get your flu shot? You can find a place to get one here: VaccineFinder.org.
Questions about influenza vaccination for older people? Comments? Post them below!
This article was reviewed and updated in October 2019.
Note: Over the past few years there have been occasional comments from readers complaining that my information on vaccination is inaccurate. I’ve decided to stop approving and responding to these comments. BetterHealthWhileAging.net exists to share what I consider “mainstream geriatrics,” which concurs with the public health recommendations from the CDC. People who disagree with these expert recommendations are free to hold their own opinions and can find other spaces online to post such opinions.
Q. What do you recommend for Cancer patients undergoing chemo or radiation or surgery or other therapies… please share qualified links (not ads) on this topic. It will be helpful and increase sucessful outcomes that are far reaching. Oxox Thank you! So thorough research based … with clear pros/cons options and probability consequences. This speaks well of not just your professionalism … but compassion. You have found your calling!
Thank you, I’m glad you find the research references helpful.
The CDC and other experts recommends influenza vaccination for people with cancer: https://www.cdc.gov/cancer/flu/index.htm. This is because having cancer or another serious illness increases one’s risk of having serious complications, if one catches the flu.
For anyone currently undergoing chemotherapy or other treatment, the best would be to ask one’s cancer specialists for their recommendation, regarding influenza vaccination.
A few years ago I had the senior flu vaccine and had a high temperature over 103. I just get the regular vaccine now. I do have some allergies to certain drugs so this much stronger vaccine may just be another one for me.
Hi Elise, I have a 50YOA daughter who makes the same claim.
What you have is a correlation is NOT causation issue. Just because you got a high temp doesn’t necessarily mean it was related to a vaccine. If you are a senior you already have immunosenescense so you need a better flu shot. Most flu deaths are seniors. Use your head get your shots. If you get a high temp call your doctor or take ibuprofen.
Be safe. Death is coming no need to hurry it along.
Sincerely,
Bob McCullough
I’m 78 with low resistance but I had the reg flu shot in Late sept. I didn’t know about the strong shot. Can I still get the new flu shot or because I had the other one I can’t?
Hi Jane. This question has come up before, and you can click here to read Dr. K’s answer. Also check out this expert Q and A. Hope this helps to reassure you.
Dear Dr. K,
This is an extraordinarily informative, clearly written article that will be helpful to people of all ages.
Thank you very much!
I’m so glad you are out there, sending sensitive, practical, compassionate advice to all of us!
Thank you!
In view of the fact that “older adults tend to create fewer antibodies in response to vaccination”, is there any validity in an older adult getting a “booster” shot in a few months (say January)?
It’s true that older adults tend to create fewer antibodies, and the immunity that is created by the vaccine will wane over the next several months.
Despite this, at this time the ACIP does not recommend a booster later in the season. They also don’t recommend that people try to get immunized later in flu season. See here for more info: http://www.immunize.org/askexperts/experts_inf.asp
Would the flu vaccines for older adults be thimerosal free? My mother is afraid of mercury since she already has dementia? Also we heard that last year they picked the wrong strain to vaccinate against? Is it still worthwhile to get the vaccine?
The CDC table listing all available influenza vaccines also lists whether or not there is thimerosal:
TABLE 1. Influenza vaccines — United States, 2017–18 influenza season
Generally it depends on whether the vaccine formulation is a single prefilled syringe versus a multidose vial. A preservative such as thimerosal is usually used in multidose vials.
The CDC considers thimerosal very safe: Thimerosal in Vaccines.
I am not aware of any correlation between thimerosal and dementia. If your mother is concerned about mercury exposure, she should bear in mind that seafood is usually a much more significant source of exposure to mercury. A 2016 autopsy study found that people who consumed more seafood did have higher levels of mercury in the brain. However, this did not correlate with higher levels of Alzheimer’s pathology; instead, people who consumed more seafood had FEWER plaques and tangles in the brain.
Association of Seafood Consumption, Brain Mercury Level, and APOE ε4 Status With Brain Neuropathology in Older Adults
If your mother has dementia and wants to minimize her risk of cognitive decline, the medical things that are most important to avoid are delirium and medications that slow brain function (e.g. anticholinergics and benzodiazepines). Delirium in particular has been associated with acceleration of cognitive decline, in people with dementia. Getting her annual flu shot can reduce her risk of getting very sick from influenza.
A common problem that speeds Alzheimer’s decline, and how to avoid it
In terms of the vaccine’s effectiveness last year, apparently the CDC considered it a “good match”, see here:
http://www.cnn.com/2017/02/16/health/flu-shot-effective-cdc-study/index.html
But it doesn’t really matter whether last year was a good match or not. The vaccine is a good enough match most years. Getting vaccinated is safe, and does reduce one’s risk somewhat during flu season.
I wasn’t aware that you request a type of influenza vaccine – that adds another level of complexity. Can you clarify about how to use the information on the different types of influenza vaccines available. If I go to the CVS for a shot, should an older person ask for a certain type?
Sorry if all the detail above has caused confusion. There are indeed several types of flu shot being manufactured, but my guess is that most providers of flu shots will only have a few flu shot options available…probably whatever they decided to purchase for this year’s flu shot season.
If you are interested in a high-dose flu shot for older adults, then you should definitely ask your doctor or the drugstore if they can provide it. Otherwise, you can ask them what other types of flu shots they are offering.
This week I had my annual physical with my GP and another annual appointment with my gynecologist. Both had ordered flu vaccines in advance of the season, neither received even a tenth of what was ordered, no high-dose were delivered at all.
This is upper East Side in Manhattan, “Bedpan Alley” because of all the medical facilities and pharmacies.
None of the Duane Reade stores had high-dose.
Found FLUAD at a CVS, got my shot, brought my husband back there hours later.
We are so fortunate to live in a country where “shortage” doesn’t mean “nothing, nowhere, for anyone.” I am thinking about all the places in the world where medicine cannot be found, where people die for lack of what we have in abundance.
Love how persistent and resourceful you were! Thank you for sharing this comment and also for reminding us how fortunate we are.
When you write “the downsides of getting a flu shot are small”, or “getting vaccinated is safe” you are ignoring the fact that the majority of dangerous reactions, (like Guillaine-Barre paralysis, severe immune dysregulation, flu like illnessses) reported by doctors to VAERS =Vaccine Adverse Events Reporting System are from the influenza vaccine. Since the CDC estimates that fewer than 1-10 of these reactions are reported by doctors, the FDA says 1-100, it’s simply not possible to estimate safety.
The adjuvant is usually aluminum, even more neurotoxic than mercury, which at least in seafood has selenium and Omega 3’s to reduce inflammation and bioavailability in crossing the blood brain barrier.
It’s true that Guillain-Barre syndrome (GBS) has been associated with influenza vaccination. But this is a rare condition (1-2 cases per 100,00) and furthermore, you can get GBS as a consequence of influenza or other viral infections. (GBS is so serious that I can’t imagine many cases not being reported to VAERS.)
The CDC and other researchers DO try to estimate safety. When they do randomized trials of influeza vaccine, all participants are monitored for adverse events. And then they also do other analysis, to determine whether the likelihood of benefit outweighs the likelihood of harm.
Most people are far far more likely to experience harm from influenza than they are to experience harm from the vaccine. For GBS, a 2014 analysis concluded that the attributable risk was 1.03 GBS cases per 1 million vaccinations.
As for the adjuvant, we don’t have much clinical experience with it in the US and I’m not able to research alumnimum at this time. Honestly I prefer to have people exposed to fewer drugs and other synthetic substances, so I would have a personal preference to avoid adjuvants unless they were shown to have a dramatically better effectiveness than Fluzone High-Dose, which has a more established track record.
Thank you for this useful advice. Since my parents and I receive influenza vaccination every year, we seldom get infected except that my mom still got Flu A and sent to the hospital in 2015, which worsen her cognitive problem with delirum.
Talking about vaccines, our government (Hong Kong) advised that one dose of PCV13 will be needed for elderly persons with high-risk conditions, followed by one dose of 23-valent pneumococcal polysaccharide vaccine (23vPPV) one year after. What are the differences between these two vaccines? Is it enough if one has received only PCV13? Can one dose of 23vPPV only in order to get sufficient protection? I also heard that if one gets one dosage in a year, then a few years later he has to receive an “additional” or sort of “enhanced” jab so as to maintain the number of antibody. Is it true?
Many thanks.
In the U.S., a one-time vaccination with PPSV23 (Pneumovax) has been recommended for older adults for quite some time, to protect against Streptococcus pneumoniae, a bacterium that can pneumonia and also other serious infections outside the lungs. Pneumovax provides protection against 23 serotypes of this bacterium. In 2014, the CDC decided to also start recommending that older adults be vaccinated with PCV13 (Prevnar), which is another type of pneumococcal vaccination. Prevnar protects against 13 serotypes of the bacteria, and offers complementary protection to Pneumovax.
Some people are vaccinated with PPSV23 earlier in life, due to having certain health problems. The CDC recommends that those individuals be re-vaccinated with PPSV23 after age 65.
For more information, see here: Pneumococcal Vaccine Timing for Adults
Pneumococcal Vaccination
M.Hill November 3, 2017
If your primary care doctor tells you that you are on the verge of Hashimoto’s disease because I have autoimmune disease .( Fibmaligialia rheumaticia 2010 thru 2012). Doctor is keeping a watch on this before medication. My question is; Will the elderly flu shot increase my autoimmune disease and cause other diseases such as lupus etc. I read this somewhere from a rheumatic doctor. Is this true?
The CDC and other experts generally recommend that people with autoimmune diseases get the seasonal flu vaccine. This is because people with autoimmune conditions are at higher risk of having flu complications, and it’s estimated that the overall risk of being harmed by the flu is higher than the small risk of developing an autoimmune exacerbation related to the vaccine.
People with autoimmune conditions should not get the live attenuated flu vaccine. (But that one is not recommended in the US this year, anyway.)
I think there are certainly some doctors who believe it’s risky for people with autoimmune issues to get the flu shot. I was not able to find much scientific evidence regarding the risk, however, so I’m not sure we really know what the risk is.
I would recommend you discuss your questions regarding the likely benefits and risks of flu vaccination with your own doctors. You may want to discuss this question with a rheumatologist, as they may have a better understanding of the guidelines and research evidence on this topic.
Good luck!
Thanks for your research on this. I will check with the rheumatologist that treated me in 2010 for fib rheumatic. He tole me not to take the flu shot then but I was on high doses of predisione at the time. Maybe that was the reason. I just saw your post on flu shots and wanted to know your thoughts. Thanks again. I enjoy your posts.
Mary Hill
Glad you are finding this site helpful.
Forgot to mention earlier: some experts hypothesize that vaccines with adjuvants are more likely to overstimulate a sensitive immune system. You may want to ask your rheum specialists for their opinion on this matter, as it relates to your personal health history.
Otherwise: the trouble with prednisone is that it suppresses the immune system, so I would expect it to render vaccination much less effective, rather than enabling vaccination to prompt an autoimmune attack on the body. But again, talk to your rheum specialists! Good luck!
Thank you so much for this information. We are both 77. I haven’t had any flu since childhood. I don’t get shots every year. Before I found Azelastine I would get sinus infections every year. It’s been at least 10 years since I’ve caught anything. This year we bothe got flu shots & pneumonia shots & now we both have Influnza B which we probably got from 17 yr old grandson. Just for “FYI”
Oh, too bad that you got sick just the year you got the flu shot. Sounds like bad luck. Hopefully you will make a quick recovery.
Azelastine is an antihistamine available as a nasal spray and also as eye drops, for people prone to get allergic inflammation of their nasal passages or eyes. Great that it’s been working well for you.
It’s startling to think that the flu can hospitalize and even kill people. As an adult, I’ve never gotten a flu shot, but now I think I may. How can I know which vaccine to get this year?
The CDC’s take is that any flu vaccine on the list for this year is acceptable.
In the “Bottom line” part of the article, I list some considerations to help people make an informed choice, if they have one.
Im 54 years never had a flu and NEVER will i put that rubbish into my HEALTHY body god knows what they are putting in those vaccines no thankyou
Some people do prefer to avoid the flu vaccine, for various reasons. Sorry but I had to delete much of your comment as it hinted at profanity and also said some disparaging things about older adults.
My 75 year old mother was diagnosed with Alzheimer’s over 5 years ago and is in the moderate stage. She lives in a memory care facility and needs help bathing and dressing, sometimes with eating. She can’t find her room and doesn’t know what happened 5 minutes ago. She sees things that aren’t there. It is not safe for her to be alone at all. She has recently fallen twice, and now has multiple fractures of her pelvis. She’s in a nursing home for rehab and we don’t know if she’ll walk independently again. She has a POLST and also a healthcare directive and does not want any interventions, comfort care only. I am her power of attorney. She is no longer herself, and is miserable at times when she recognizes that she is not herself. She has previously received a flu vaccine every year, but I’m considering no longer getting her vaccinated, believing that, should she get the flu, it is more humane for her misery to end sooner rather than later.
Thanks for sharing your story. Well, it sounds like based on your mother’s declining health and what you perceive as her preferences, your goals for her medical care are that it keep her comfortable, rather than postpone death. That’s often a very reasonable approach.
I explain addressing goals of care and how one might scale back life-prolonging medical care in this article: How to Plan for Decline in Alzheimer’s Dementia:A 5-Step Approach to Navigating Difficult Decisions & Crises with Less Stress.
Good luck and take care, it’s wonderful that you’re carefully thinking about what kind of medical care is the best fit for your mother, given her values and her condition.
Thank you Dr. Kernisian for your reply and the link to the article. It was extremely validating, particulary as my mom was readmitted to the hospital with a raging urinary tract infection. She is doing better and likely going back to rehab, but only until I can find a new living situation for her and begin hospice. She did/does not want the revolving door of hospital admissions. I wish there were more geriatricians willing to be so honest and pragmatic.
My 85 yo Mthr has the over 65 vaccine today along with me. Her BP is 181/78-191/82. Is there some ingredient in the vaccine 2018 that might cause this increase???? She takes 2 type of BP
Meds.
For unusually high BP associated with vaccination, I would say it’s more likely that the high BP is due to pain or anxiety about the medical encounter, rather than due to the vaccine itself. It is fairly common for people to spike their blood pressure when they are upset, hurt, or anxious.
You could try checking her BP at home every day for a few days. If it remains higher than expected, then it would be a good idea to contact her usual health providers to ask for advice.
I have more on managing BP here: 6 Steps to Better High Blood Pressure Treatment for Older Adults. Good luck!
Is there an advantage to waiting and getting the flu shot closer to the flu season…maybe in late November or early December?
See this comment above, which is closely related to your question.
Although influenza activity usually peaks between December and February, there is often a fair bit of influenza activity in November. It takes about two weeks for the body to respond to the flu vaccine. The CDC and other experts recommend being vaccinated by the end of October.
Thank you….I’m off to get my flu shot!
Dr. Kernisian, I just want to say how amazing it is that you respond to all questions! So great.
Thanks for all of your hard work.
I do this in hopes that my answering the question publicly will be useful to other readers. Thank you for your comment, I appreciate it!
Hello, I work as an RN in a large clinic system that is only offering Flublok Quadrivalent vaccine for individuals 65 years and older this year (in the past they have always offered Fluzone High-Dose). My husband is 72 years old and has several chronic medical conditions and does not leave the house very often. He could go to a pharmacy in order to get the Fluzone High-Dose vaccine. He is hesitating in making a decision because it will require about 2-3 hours more effort and time to go to the pharmacy for the High Dose vaccine than if I just bring the Flublok vaccine home to him. Do you have a suggestion in this circumstance? Thank you for this excellent web site and pod cast— I always learn so much!
Hm, interesting dilemma. Well, my interpretation of the data is that in general, the high-dose vaccine is more likely to provide protection from influenza or serious influenza complications.
That said, it’s hard to quantify just how much additional protection your husband, as an individual, is likely to get from Fluzone high dose vs Flublok, and whether that is worth 2-3 hours of his time and effort. The CDC, after all, does not particularly recommend the vaccines developed for older adults; they say that what is most important is to get a flu vaccine. It’s also currently impossible to know whether this year’s vaccine will be a good match for the flu, and what kind of flu season we’ll have.
Really, I think you could go either way. In general, the absolute benefit of vaccination for an older person who doesn’t leave the house much is small. So if he’s unwell and it’s a burden to leave the house, it sounds reasonable to just go with Flublok. But if you and he want to feel you’ve done more to minimize his risk, then it’s also reasonable to try to get Fluzone high-dose. Good luck!
Thanks! These comments will help us decide 🙂
“Really, I think you could go either way. In general, the absolute benefit of vaccination for an older person who doesn’t leave the house much is small. ”
Does this response mean if a older person, age 89 doesn’t leave the house very often, only occasional visits to doctor, would you recommend they NOT have the vaccine at all. Someone is telling me to do that for my mother. It kind of makes sense, but I want to do the right thing.
If you could respond to this, I’d be grateful!. Thank you.
So, I can’t make a recommendation for your situation in particular. In general, when considering whether to recommend something or recommend against it, what I consider is:
– what are the likely benefits of getting this intervention?
– What are the likely burdens?
– What are the risks?
– What are the goals for this person’s medical care? How important is it to try to prolong life, versus minimizing distress?
For instance, an older person who has advanced dementia, is bedbound, and whose family has opted to stop trying to prolong life, in this case vaccinating against the flu probably doesn’t make much sense.
Generally we do recommend vaccination, unless it’s quite distressing or burdensome to an older adult, or unless the goals of medical care are really focused on comfort. Hope this helps.
Dr. Kernisan, Thank you for taking the time to write this very detailed account of the Flu vaccine.
I am a 73 yo prostate cancer patient who wants to prevent dying from vaccine preventable diseases.
Q. Is it true that the again approved nasal spray (vaccine)? using an inactivated virus could cause the
flu infection on immune compromised patients? Especially non vaccinated patients?
Q. I hope you can find some info on the aluminum adjuvant used in vaccines because of the antivax
objections.
Q. You mentioned the thimerosal required by the FDA in the 5 shot vaccines vials. The needles
breaking the seal to remove the vaccine can, and have, injected other dangerous germs with bad
consequences. My understanding is that the mercury used is ethyl mercury which the human
body quickly and safely eliminates. The more dangerous mercury is methyl mercury which was
used in dental work. It is called amalgam and here is the FDA’s reference: https://www.fda.gov/medicaldevices/productsandmedicalprocedures/dentalproducts/dentalamalgam/ucm171094.htm
Because of the naïve mercury objections, most Flu vaccine are the more expensive single dose vials.
Q. The CDC recommends against getting both the HD trivalent vaccine and a quadrivalent flu vaccine.
I was thinking that even a standard extra B Flu antigen in the quadrivalent vaccine would be better
then only the one B antigen of the trivalent. Any suggestions as to why they are against double
shots?
Q. The CDC use to recommend the flu shots especially for American Indians, Eskimos and other
indigenous peoples. (Now the recommend flu shots for everyone over 6 months old with few
exceptions,) I wonder why the HD Flu vaccine is not recommended for other immunocompromised
patients?
Q. The herd immunity for the Flu is 95% To achieve this high rate would you agree that these shots
should not only be free but one days worth of unemployment should be awarded to all who have
successfully had their shot?
Q. Can you tell us about the Universal Influenza vaccine? I understand that there is one soon to be
available.
Q. Do you know about an upcoming RSV vaccine especially tailored for the elderly?
Q. Would you recommend the Shingrix vaccine, which has an adjuvant, be given at the same time as
the flu vaccine?
Q. It is recommended that seniors get a Tdap vaccine because of the pertussis issue with newborns.
Do you see a problem with getting the Tdap with the Flu vaccine?
Q. Do you recommend getting an MMR vaccine booster shot? Could the MMR also be done with the
flu shot?
Thank you for your valuable time.
Q.
Appreciate your interest in the article, however you have asked a lot of detailed questions and I’m afraid I just don’t have the time and bandwidth to respond to them all. Answering many of your questions would require reviewing the scientific literature, the CDC guidance, and more. Briefly:
– The nasal vaccine (which contains live virus) is not approved for people aged 50 or older, so I don’t spend much time researching the details.
– Most influenza vaccines do not contain alumnium. The Fluad vaccine probably does. The CDC comments on the risks of adjuvants here.
– I don’t generally question the CDC’s guidance or another expert society’s guidance (unless it falls into one of those domains where geriatricians sometimes draw different conclusions that other specialists do). So I can’t comment on why the CDC is against double immunization, or why they are not recommending HD flu vaccine for certain populations.
– I don’t know much about the Universal Influenza Vaccine initiative, but interested people can learn more on this NIH site: Universal Influenza Vaccine Research
– I have not been following research on a potential RSV vaccine
– I have not yet decided what position to publicly declare, if any, regarding Shingrix and the adjuvant. I generally prefer to recommend interventions and vaccines that have a proven track record, which Shingrix won’t have for a few years.
– Yes, it’s generally considered ok to get influenza vaccine at the same time as Tdap, see here.
– The CDC says that people born before 1957 do not need the MMR, because almost everyone is presumed to have been exposed to measles, mumps and rubella during childhood.
Hope this helps!
Thanks so much for your comprehensive and understanding information about flu shots (and many other subjects).
Thank you, I’m so glad you find the site informative. Appreciate this feedback as it helps me keep going.
I never have had a flu shot. Last year I had the flu for the first time I can remember(I am 66) It was a rather classic case and was followed by a UTI. My husband(69) also got it and was followed by infected saliva glands. I did a bit of flu research while convalescing and am under the impression that having had the flu last year can afford me as much protection from future flu as an unmatched flu shot. What do you think? I’ve read a lot about my older compromised immune system so was pretty impressed with its performance last year. I dud get the pneumonia vaccine this year after I understood it’s a life time immunity, unlike the flu shot. However I am considering a flu shot, but was informed to wait until the second half of October. I’ve been fortunate to be extremely healthy all my life but am surprised at the different results I get when researching if I google in “geriatric”. It’s a totally different field with different results and it seems to me not that fewer ” geriatrics” are included in drug trials yet they are the largest population of recipients of prescribed meds. I am appalled that there’s not more warnings about the use of OTC meds that are brain disruptive to the elderly. Thank you for your website and the issues you address.
Thank you for sharing your story and these comments. I’m so glad you find the site helpful.
Agree that OTC medications that are brain disruptive (namely anticholinergics such as Benadryl, PM painkillers, and OTC sleep aids) should be more clearly labeled as risky for older adults. So glad you are aware of this issue!
Re including older adults in research, this is indeed an important issue. There have been some influenza vaccination studies done in older adults, although how they define “older” varies.
I’m not aware of much research on how having the flu the year prior might protect against influenza the following season. The safest approach is to get the annual flu shot.
Since you are 66 and describe yourself as “extremely healthy,” I would guess that your immune system is still doing pretty well, even though it’s probably not as vigorous as it was 30 years ago. This means you’re likely to have a good response to the flu vaccine. good luck!
You mentioned that being young you don’t think you will get seriously ill from the flu…. that’s not true… a TV broadcaster from Cleveland Ohio got the flu and died last year.. she was 37!!! She became septic and died quickly.. Her name was Kathleen Cochran from Fox 8 News…
Yes, it’s true that even younger healthy people can get sick and die from the flu. This happened several times last year, it was very sad.
That said, these deaths are statistically an unusual event. Even last year, when the strain of flu going around was particularly bad, the vast majority of younger healthy people infected with influenza did not get hospitalized.
Hence as I write in the article, I’m not that concerned about getting dangerously ill from influenza. I get myself vaccinated because it does reduce my chances of getting sick and feeling miserable for several days, and also because it helps protect my patients and others. It also reduces my risk of getting dangerously ill, but in absolute terms, it’s a very small reduction in risk for healthy younger people.
My Doctor’s nurse gave me (age 79) regular flu vaccine by mistake even tho I asked for high dose Fluzone. Should I proceed with the Fluzone shot? Will the 2 shots cause any harm?
Hm. The CDC says that any flu shot approved for your age is acceptable, and experts generally recommend against revaccinating during the flu season. I don’t know what harm might be expected from two shots concurrently, I’m not aware of that being studied.
I would recommend discussing your concerns with your doctor. It’s probably reasonable to just stick with the one flu vaccine you received.
It is good that you mentioned that as we grow older, our immune systems are inclined to respond less to immunization. If that is the case, the younger we are, the better we take advantage of the flu shots to avoid influenza virus that can be dangerous to our health and body. To make sure we are safe from that virus, I will advise my husband and children to have a flu shot annually to bolster our immune system.
I am 83 years old and have diabetes, atrial fibrillation, polymyalgia rheumatica, osteoarthritis and hypertension, all of which have been fairly well controlled with medication. I am on Xarelto, glipizide, metformin, sotalol, small amount of prednisone, metoprolol, vitamin D3 and vitamin B12. Ten days ago I received the Fluzone high-doze flu vaccination. My arm was quite sore for the next few days and my arm was blotchy red. I also had a runny nose and pretty severe frontal headache with a cough at night and fairly severe increased muscle aches for several days. Today (the 10th day after receiving) I am still just really tired and sometimes get out of breath just doing small chores. I received my vaccine at the CVS local pharmacy. I have not contacted anyone yet, neither my internal medicine doctor or my cardiologist. I have recently had extensive heart tests and lab tests which were all good. Each doctor seems to blame my complaints when I call them on “stress.” I am a fairly recent widow and I think that is probably a common complaint of widows. I am hesitating to call them to be told again that my problem is stress. I don’t feel like what is happening to me Is life-threatening but I am just concerned that I am still so tired–like I am just getting over the flu. Have you had any experience with this in an older person? Thanks for your help.
Well, some people do feel like they have a reaction to the flu shot. That said, if you are still feeling so tired and also short of breath, I would be careful about attributing this to the flu shot, especially since it’s been 10 days since you had it. There are number of health problems that could cause the symptoms you’re experiencing, and just because your tests were fine recently doesn’t mean something can’t have happened or evolved since then.
Given your age, your chronic conditions, and your many medications, if you are feeling tired and short of breath it’s entirely reasonable to ask to be evaluated by your usual doctor or even in urgent care. Good luck!
Thank you very much for responding so quickly. I agree with all of your comments. I did get out of the house today and found that I had a little more energy than I thought. Maybe I needed some fresh air. My blood sugar is good, my blood pressure within normal limits, the redness is much better on my arm–no blotching anywhere else. If my symptoms of tiredness and shortness of breath continue tomorrow, I will seek out a nearby urgent care center to listen to my lungs and possibly check my platelets and/or blood counts. I try to avoid ER because my last trip there in April resulted in a shockingly horrendous bill. I have been on Xarelto for about 6 months this time (after trying Pradaxa, Equilis, Jantoven, etc. with complications); and sometimes I feel that Xarelto may be responsible for some of my shortness of breath but I have no choice but to stay on it. Thanks again
Today is 18 days past my flu shot, and I still am feeling badly. I became so tired last evening and had somewhat of a nervous meltdown about my condition that my son insisted on taking me to an ER near my house. I have been very worried about my condition. I was not treated very well by the NP in the ER. His first question was why did I not return to the place where I received the vaccine, which I had administered at a CVS pharmacy. I had talked with them on Monday and they had no reports so far about such extreme effects. And a pharmacy cannot treat me. I called the CDC in Atlanta on Tuesday and they would give me no medical results or recommendations, would send me a complaint card. In the ER, a lot of blood work was done and the results were all good as far as CBC, sed rate (which is normally elevated because of PMR), c-reactive protein, etc. He dismissed me to home with recommendation to just drink plenty of liquids. I’m still feeling so tired and occasionally having headaches. I have no appetite and still have loose bowels. I am at my wit’s end. I don’t know what to do. If I could just communicate with someone who has been through this and could hear them say that: “You will be OK, just have patience and don’t be scared.” Can anyone give me advice?
Sorry you’re still feeling unwell. Many things get better eventually, with time and especially with rest and a restorative environment. But I cannot say what’s likely for you. I hope you start feeling better soon and if not, I hope you find a health provider who can be helpful.
It is now 6 weeks past my having received the over-65 flu vaccine as I have stated above. I have had two trips to the ER, one visit to a walk-in clinic, a visit with my ophthalmologist and a visit to my rheumatologist. All tests at 3 different times have been “within normal limits” except for my C-reactive protein, which was 1.39 mg/dL with normal being 0.00 to 0.50 mg/dL. My extensive research tells me that this is apparently not enough to indicate that I have a recurrence of my temporal arteritis. I have definitely had a flare of my polymyalgia rheumatica. I still have headaches and an abnormal intestinal tract. My life has certainly been affected by the vaccine. What really concerns me is the lack of concern shown by most people I have seen. Like, “Just give it some time.” It has been 43 days of misery for me, being scared that I will not be able to continue taking care of myself. I have read extensively about the problems this has caused older people who have an autoimmune disease and especially the writings of a physician at the Cleveland Clinic. I wish that I had read these writings before I received the vaccine. I think the CDC or the FDA or some regulatory agency should give more warnings to the public about this. The agencies that I have called do not seem to be interested in my opinions. They say they will send me a form to complete. Well, truthfully, I don’t have the energy to complete those forms. Thank you for listening to my complaints.
Sorry you have been feeling unwell. Perhaps you can share some links to what you are reading regarding the flu vaccine in older adults with autoimmune disease?
It is too bad if you feel people haven’t shown enough concern. I imagine that even if they are concerned, they don’t see any reason to hospitalize you and they aren’t sure what they can do to further evaluate you or help you feel better. Although we know a lot about the body (compared to 100 years ago), in some cases it still seems mysterious and we are unable to explain what might be going on.
Hope you start feeling better soon!
I had an autoimmune disease (polymaligia rheumatica } for 2 years in 2010 – 2012. I was diagnosed with autoimmune antibodies of RA, Lupus, and Syrogyn antibodies. I have not had elderly flu shot or other since and afraid the toxins from it and the shot messing with my immune system will cause flareup of the antibodies. Have you any information on this?
Someone has already asked about the flu shot and autoimmune disease, please see my response above.
Basically, the CDC and many other experts recommend that people with autoimmune disease get the seasonal influenza vaccine.
If you have concerns, I would recommend discussing with a rheumatologist or with your usual health provider.
Mary, you may be wise not to get the stronger vaccine. If you are interested, read my various writings above what the vaccine has done to me. Each person has to make his own decision, but I wish that someone would have warned me about the possible outcome with getting the stronger vaccine especially about all of the antigens it contains. I have been sick for 43 days, but I am slowly improving. I occasionally will have a relapse of one of my symptoms, seems to be never-ending.
Anna, although you have had a difficult time with your health since getting the flu vaccine, overall the number of such reactions (if what you are having truly is a reaction to the flu shot) is much smaller than the number older adults who are hospitalized due to influenza every year.
For most older adults, the likely benefits of the flu vaccine outweigh the likely risks.
Dr. Kernisan, I realize what you say is true, and I have wanted to be careful that I do not encourage anyone to neglect getting the flu vaccine. My concern is that there should be more warnings for people who suffer from autoimmune diseases to avoid the over-65 vaccine. I had received regular flu vaccines for more than 15 years without any problems at all. I had listed all of my health problems and medications on the form that I completed at the facility where I received the vaccine. If the pharmacist had read it, she should have known not to give me the stronger dose had she been educated about the possible results. I asked her if I would have any side effects from the vaccine she gave me, and her reply was “possibly only a sore arm and a low-grade fever.” Well, I wish that would have been all. It’s now 8 weeks and I am still having problems, but I am much better; so hopefully one day I will recover completely. Thank you for all of your help.
As far as I know, the CDC and other authorities have not yet issued any warnings that the stronger flu shot should not be given to people with autoimmune diseases. It is not clear to me that this is a known risk yet. So I would not expect a pharmacist or generalist to counsel you regarding this issue.
Furthermore, even if there was an increased risk of illness in people such as yourself, before issuing a blanket caution, the CDC would want to determine whether the risk was greater than the risk of serious flu-related illness. For instance, the CDC has determined that there may be a small increased risk of Guillan-Barre syndrome with the flu vaccine, however the increased risk is very small (the CDC estimates it at one to two additional GBS cases per million doses of flu vaccine administered), and so for most people, the likely benefit of influenza vaccination vastly outweighs the risk.
I am very sorry for your prolonged recent illness, but I have to again say that from a science perspective, it’s impossible to know whether it was due to your influenza vaccination or not. I try to allow people to express themselves in the comments but I’m not comfortable with readers drawing medical conclusions from their single experience and advising others on this basis. An individual’s experience can generate a hypothesis but no more; when such hypothesis are subjected to rigorous medical study, many of them do not hold up.
The take away that I would recommend, from your story, is that people with a history of autoimmune disease should consider consulting their rheumatologist or personal physician, for help assessing the risks and benefits of vaccination with the standard flu vaccine or stronger one.
I do appreciate your being part of our community and hope you continue your recovery.
Dr. Kernisan: I certainly understand all of your above statements and respect you as a scientist and professional. When I recover more fully, I will retrace my many steps in trying to find answers to giving the stronger flu vaccine to patients with autoimmune diseases and try to give you some citations of research that has been done. At the present time, I get very nervous and agitated when I try to overextend my foggy brain and trying to understand scientific data. There is a website in which lay people like me express their opinions about the vaccine, not necessarily perhaps about the over-65 one. There are several people who have had situations similar to mine. It makes me feel somewhat better to know that I was not the only person affected (misery loves company!!!)
You might find this interesting. Have a great New Year!!
https://www.medicinenet.com/flu_vaccination/patient-comments-859.htm
“But not every older person is interested in doing everything possible to reduce the danger of illness. Vaccination is important from a public health perspective, but most people survive flu season whether or not they’ve been vaccinated.”
Wow, Guilt trip? I’m 70 years old and happen to be one of “those” who in not “interested” in getting a flu shot. In fact, I have never received a flu shot and neither has my husband, nor my parents or grandparents. None of my children or grandchildren have either. Every “season” when others around us, have received a shot and get sick, we all skate through with nary a cold or problem. I have refused vaccines for the past 55+ years and see no reason to not continue to do so. In my mind, it’s all poison, and I’m not “interested.”
Sorry for delayed reply, we had a glitch in our system that we have just resolved.
Well, you have a right to opt to not get a flu shot. I do believe vaccination reduces symptomatic flu in the population during years when there’s a good match, so I’d say you are gaining some small reduction in flu risk if enough people around you do get vaccinated.
I hope you continue to skate through as you have done.
One of the most informative articles regarding flu vaccines. Thank you! Two comments: I have heard that the reason the CDC doesn’t recommend a given flu shot for seniors is that it may not be available in their area — and they fear some will opt not to get a shot as a result. Second, why is there no high-dose quadrivalent shot available? It would seem that would provide the ultimate protection to those over 65?
Thank you, I’m glad you found it helpful. I will actually be updating it next week, for the 2019-2020 flu season.
I don’t know why there is no high-dose quadrivalent shot available…presumably there is a reason the manufacturer Sanofi doesn’t make a Fluzone high dose quadrivalent.
Thanks. Tremendous article on flu.
Thank you, I’m glad you found it helpful. An updated version will be available in about 10 days, but I don’t expect there will be any major changes to the information.
Thanks for all the info on the flu,I had flu shot in late Dec 2018,do i need another one now.No one has given me any answers,tnks.
Yes, you should get another flu shot now. The flu vaccines are recreated every year (this begins in early spring), with antigens based on what flu experts expect will be the main circulating strains for the coming flu season.
My husband and I, 71 & 70 years old, get the flu shot every Fall. This year, no one had the vaccine recommended for seniors in stock and no information about when it would become available again, so we took the regular vaccine, We decided that some protection was better than none. If the senior vaccine becomes available later, should we take it or get a 2nd of the regular strength vaccine?
Per this expert Q&A, the Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices does not recommend revaccination later in the season.
So if you’ve already been vaccinated, I would leave it at that. Remember, the likelihood that flu vaccination will prevent hospitalization or death for any single individual is actually fairly small. Also, although I think it makes sense for older adults to get the high-dose vaccination when possible, the CDC’s official take is that any approved influenza vaccination is acceptable. Good luck and take care!
Dr. Kernisan,
Your advice re influenza vaccination is a “tour de force.”
Your efforts remind me of the person in a recent ProPublica article who has been a selfless backstop against computer ransomware.
Thank You!
Thank you so much for this comment, it means a lot to me.
Is there any reason for administering injections into the arm? I have had to have B12 injections every month for 30 years, and I found as I aged that injections into the hip are much less painful. Last year every one I knew who got a flu shot, did get a sore arm or shoulder.
Thank you for your sensitive and caring way of imparting information and dealing with the wide range of responses to your articles. Your work is deeply appreciated!
Hm, interesting question!
The vaccine is supposed to be injected intramuscularly. The ACIP’s guidance recommends the deltoid for adults (including older adults) but notes that the anterolateral thigh can also be used: https://www.cdc.gov/vaccines/hcp/acip-recs/general-recs/administration.html
Since many people feel some soreness after influenza vaccination, I think I’d prefer being injected in the arm than the leg. But you could certainly ask your health provider if an injection in the thigh is an option.
I am 89, independent and always get a flu shot but am afraid to this year. Last year I immediately had a pain in lower back and down my legs and couldn’t navigate. They say me down called EMS My blood pressure shot up to 180s. After 1/2 hour to 45 minutes, I gradually regained legs etc and eventually went home. I didn’t know anything about Willis Barre until researching. Also a few weeks later I developed many different types of sore and rashes. Don’t know if it was related. I didn’t know I should report it so didn’t. Asking my Dr this year let’s just say he wouldn’t believe me! I didn’t go to him but to a dermatologist when I developed skin problems. They were unsuccessful treating me and sent me to Oncologist who took me off aspirin 81 and a blood pressure medication and through prednisone for quite awhile. I went back periodically for observation and released couple weeks ago.
I feel I’m between a rock and hard place! I believe in flu shot. Scared to take strong elderly shot. Think I had Fluad but may have forgotten. Do you think I dare get the regular shot for younger adults? No use asking my Dr. The pharmacist who witnessed the event said to see my Dr. I understand not wanting them to give advice. Your thoughts? Barbara
Hi Barabra, I’m sorry to hear about the challenges you have had! It can be difficult to sort out a cause and effect sometimes, so I understand you feeling concerned about getting the flu shot this year.
I am going to assume that you mean “Guillain-Barré” syndrome when you mention Willis-Barre. This is a neurological condition that affects the nerves that extend into the limbs and other parts of the body from the brain and spinal cord. The symptoms include numbness, tingling and weakness in the limbs. Most people with GBS make a complete recovery but it is a serious condition. The cause or triggering event in GBS is not known, but it may be related to an immune system process.
In the US, the Food and Drug Administration, and the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, reviewed how many Medicare recipients who got the flu vaccine also developed GBS (1), and found that there was no increased risk of GBS for the standard vaccine and a very slight increased risk for the high dose vaccine (an additional 1 case per million people). Unfortunately this study did not look at the Fluad vaccine, however, in the Italian study that Dr. K refers to, there was no increased risk of getting GBS in those who had the Fluad.
Bottom line: all flu vaccines appear to be extremely safe and for most, the risk of the vaccine is far outweighed by the potential benefit to the individual and to society. However, caution should be used in those who have had GBS within 6 weeks of a flu vaccine, and in Canada, where I practice, the recommendation is to avoid the flu vaccine in that case. Anyone who has had a serious reaction to the flu shot (more than a sore arm or mild flu-like symptoms) should talk to their health care provider to balance the risk and benefit in their particular case,
1. Vaccine Volume 37, Issue 43, 8 October 2019, Pages 6543-6549 Surveillance for Guillain-Barré syndrome after 2015–2016 and 2016–2017 influenza vaccination of Medicare beneficiaries
Deepa P.Aryaa1Maria A.Saida2Hector S.IzurietaaSilviaPerez-Vilara, et.al.
I’m not going to become an obnoxious presence but having just reviewed this long piece on flu shots I want to add, to a question I submitted a few minutes ago, this: As a former and longtime magazine editor and writer, I appreciate clarity, structure, thoughtful, detailed content and all the other good stuff that goes into excellent writing. This flu-shot post is a model of not just extremely helpful medical advice but solid journalism. And it’s typical of what I’m finding as I browse through other recent posts. Don’t know how you find the time to produce so much first-rate material in addition to treating patients, but sure glad you do. So commendable! Thank you.
Ah well, thank you! Since you are wondering how I find the time: I just published a post explaining what goes into producing and maintaining Better Health While Aging, you can learn more here: Next Steps for BHWA & Can We Remain Ad-Free?
Glad to have you as part of our reader community!
My husband and I are in our late 50s, we had the flu shot (regular from the Giant store/pharmacy) last October. We planned a trip to Southeast Asia this early March. After all what is going on with this ” flu virus” do you think we should get a second dose of flu shot before going on our trip. I will feel better if we got it but I want your opinion on this. Thanks for your time.
You are probably wondering about the current pandemic of novel coronavirus that originated in Wuhan, China. There is no vaccine against this virus currently, and an additional flu shot will not add any type of protection. I would consult the travel advisories on the US department of state website, here, or here if you are in Canada, like me.